Let me explain it with a very simple example, a real-life experience. When we go to the fair with kids, buying tickets for rides leaves us with 2 choices. Either pay per ride or buy a fixed price ticket for unlimited rides. In the beginning, pay per ride is a better option as we are not sure how many rides kids are going to do. So we usually choose pay per ride. As it goes, we pay per ride and kids though may not want to take all the rides but like to take their favorite rides again and again. We end up paying more as compared to the fixed price ticket.
For high-volume traders, Unlimited brokerage plans per month are the best fit.
Updates on Unlimited Trading Plans:
Investors may choose the Unlimited Trading Plans option for many reasons:
The fixed brokerage/unlimited trading plans are good for active investors, where they do average 20+ trading per day. In this case you will recover your money in 2 trading session. After that you will enjoy "zero brokerage unlimited trading" completely free. By using fixed brokerage/unlimited trading plans investor can do more trade in small movemement of market. Other charges like STT, stamp duty, transaction charges, GST and so on still need to paid by investor.
The pricing model that works for one type of investor may not work for another. It is also possible that a pricing model that suits one broker may not suit another. Selecting a perfect online discount broker depends on the type of trader you are. i.e. - active trader, high-volume trader or penny stock trader, short term investor or long term investor.
Active traders make many trades throughout the day. They attempt to profit from the daily price fluctuation of a particular stock. Usually Active Traders don't hold the securities for the long term.
As the frequency of trade is much higher, active trader always looks for low brokerage online trading account. Active trader prefer strong & reliable trading platform, lowest brokerage charges for online trading. Most brokers are providing online trading platform with cutting edge technologies. In such case only competition is in lowest brokerage. Discount brokers in India are providing low brokerage trading account in two ways -
For Active trader, "zero brokerage unlimited trading plan" is the best. Where they need to pay fixed monthly brokerage and get unlimited trading.
You can check the best brokers in India to provide monthly plans in this article-Top 5 brokers by monthly plans in India
Long Term Investor invests and hold equity over an extended period of time to create wealth in the long run. In long term holding you need not to pay lofty short-term capital gains taxes.
For Long Term Investor zero brokerage trading is best. Brokers like Zerodha, Upstox, Fyers offers Zero Delivery Brokerage. They can hold the script for long term or can BTST to get overnight price movement.
The flat monthly charges can be by segment or for any segment, its depend from broker to broker.
Here we are providing the details of best online stock brokers with unlimited trading plans.
As per SEBI guidelines, the broker is allowed to charge brokerage only on trading. So brokers who are providing unlimited trading plan will not charges brokerage upfront. In the unlimited trading plan, the broker takes most brokerages allowed by SEBI which is 2.5%. Once he gets his monthly plan equivalent amount. After that, he will not charge any brokerage or 1 paisa brokerage for remaining of your trades.
Example: Assume, on day-1 you have done trading of Rs 10,000 @ 2.5%, your brokerage will be Rs 250. If you have a Rs 899 Monthly plan, a broker is going to charge 250 as a brokerage. Assume on day-2 you have done trading of Rs 50,000 @ 2.5% your brokerage is Rs 1250. So you are going to charge 899-250 =Rs 649 as your brokerage. By day 3rd onwards you are going to charge 1 Paisa which is negligible till the calendar month end.
The Client needs to pay GST on brokerage. With an unlimited plan, you need to pay GST on the amount you get charged as brokerage. I.e. If you have Rs 899 per month plan, you need to pay GST on Rs 899.
As of July-2017, you need to pay 18% GST on your brokerage.
When you join an unlimited trading plan in any day of the month, you need to pay full fees of the plan. After that 1 paisa brokerage (which is negligible) amount. There is no prorated brokerage concept in unlimited trading plans.
No, the broker charge brokerage only when you do trading. So in case of any given calendar month if you have not done any trading, you donít have to pay monthly brokerage charges.
With growing competition, there is no contract with any plan and no termination fee. Users can switch the plan as per their convenience. But still, you have to check with the broker you choose.
No, Zerodha doesn't have unlimited trading plans. Zerodha support free delivery base trading. Please refer article on Zerodha's trading plans
Yes, but still you have to check with the broker you choose.
In fixed monthly plan, brokers receive a fixed payment. Fix price brokerage revenues are predictable and timely and thus are less risky.
Let's take a scenario of buffet restaurants, where you eat unlimited by paying a fixed price. You can eat as much food as you like at no extra charge. Restaurant owners may be able to do so by volume business model which reduce the cost. Thus, in a flat rate context, increasing consumption decreases the per unit price.
Same way discount brokers also performing. By increasing volume and cutting down costs. By offering online trading from centralize location is the key to offer low rates to end clients.
Fixed price models or unlimited trading plans allow customers to lock their monthly expense. The brokers who offer unlimited trading plans are a bit conservative in the margin policy. So if you are a day trader and looking for higher margin. You need to do the due diligence of each broker offering before deciding on the best-fit pricing model for you.
Last updated on 21st May 2019